Sunday, March 12, 2023

Pervez Musharaff — My Memoirs

In the last few years, relations between India and Pakistan have always been tense and turbulent. Once upon a time after the nations were torn during independence and post Bangladesh independence war, there was peace between India and Pakistan, trade flourished between the nations, Indian cinemas were opened for the Pakistani public after decades, the Indian cricket board saved the Pakistan cricket board from financial bankruptcy, and many more. All this happened during the Musharraf era when he was ruling the country as dictator and president. As a chief architect of the Kargil War, he caused the unnecessary loss of 527 Indian soldiers and innumerable Pakistan soldiers lives from the Kargil war. From the 1971 war to 2007 India-Pakistan relations, Musharraf has played a critical role. Musharraf, former dictator and president of Pakistan, passed away on Feb 5. As a regular follower of India-Pakistan & South Asian geopolitics for the last few years, I am writing a few of the memoirs that I observed about him in news in the last 3 decades.




Initial Years, 1971 war



During his initial childhood years, Musharaff was brought up in Turkey. He was an admirer of Kemal Atatürk and his vision of a Muslim state with modern secular deposition. His admiration was visible when he quoted in 2005 that Pakistan wants to become a modern state, and not a Westernized state, which is another shade of extremism.

When India and Pakistan went to war in 1971, he was one of the last soldiers planned to be sent from West Pakistan to East Pakistan. But the war ended bitterly even before he reached East Pakistan (current Bangladesh). Pakistan lost half of its nation. This created ever-lasting trauma within him. Once when he was asked about the 1971 war, he responded “I broke down and cried. All my brave soldiers cried with me. It remains a most sad and most painful day of my life. My anger at the General who had taken charge of the government and at some of the politicians of the time, still makes me see red”.

During the 1971 war, Musharaff lost one of his batchmate and close friend namely Major Rana Bilal Ahmed. In his memory, Musharaff named his only son Bilal.

Kargil War


Musharaff was a brigadier and commanded troops during India — Pakistan Siachen skirmishes in 1986. After India captured Siachen glacier heights, Musharaff tried multiple attempts to recapture Siachen heights, but all his attempts to dislodge Indian troops failed. This Siachen obsession drove him to make a blueprint for the Kargil war.

When Benazir Bhutto who was then the Prime Minister of Pakistan, in 1996 learnt about Musharaff Kargil’s plans through intelligence networks, she warned the general not to go ahead, as the war will end in humiliating status for Pakistan in world geopolitics.

In October 1998, fearing risk in his rule from Jahangir Karamat (chief of army staff, COAS, of Pakistan Army — 1998), Nawaz Sharif who was the Prime Minister appointed Musharaff the COAS, firing Jahangir Karamat. At that time, Musharaff was little known to the outside world. Nawaz Sharif believed Musharaff and Ziauddin (ISI chief -1998) will keep their job safe, but the opposite happened a few months later.

In 1999, defiant Musharaff went ahead with his Kargil plans. His plan was simple and tactical: capture the Kargil mountains in winter, overlook Indian National Highway 1 (NH1) from mountain heights, cut the supply lines going from Srinagar to Leh, and bring international mediation for the Kashmir issue. NH1 is the lifeline for troops staying in Leh and Siachen glacier. It is only land route through which logistics supplies needed for the army in Leh are delivered through trucks. In the winter of 1998, Pakistan troops of the Northern Light Infantry captured the Kargil mountains in name of irregulars. Panicked India, responded swiftly bringing back troops, howitzers, and aircraft to fight against intruders. With a combined Indian military response and international pressure, all intruders were pushed back giving a humiliating defeat to Musharaff’s plans. The entire Kargil operation was secretly executed by Musharaff keeping Nawaz sharif in dark about the Kargil.
Nawaz Sharif & Musharaff during Kargil
Kargil War — India Victory

Kashmir post-Kargil war, coup, Agra Summit



In 1999, Nawaz sharif’s move to instate Musharaff as COAS backfired. After a few months of an uneasy relationship with Sharif & Kargil humiliation, Musharaff toppled sharif’s rule and banished him to Saudi Arabia. Many countries including India condemned this move.

After Kargil’s humiliation, Musharaff and the Pakistan security establishment wanted to avenge the loss in Kashmir. Kashmir insurgency/terrorism touched its zenith when Musharaff was acting as COAS and post-Kargil war. The number of fedayeen attacks increased several times post-Kargil war. Every month, there was the loss of so many human lives including soldiers and civilians on both sides.

Even before the term “Surgical strikes” was invented, Indian and Pakistan troops often cross their respective borders, commonly known as Lines of Control and kill opponent soldiers to avenge their losses. Between 1998 and 2013, there were 9 Indian raids inside Pakistan Occupied Kashmir, as officially acknowledged by Pakistan. One of the bloodiest Pakistani raids happened in February 2000. Ilyas Kashmiri, a notorious HUJI/Al-Qaeda terrorist led a guerilla attack attacking an Indian post located in an unfavorable position surrounded on all 3 sides by Pakistani posts. All 7 soldiers inside the Indian post were killed in the attack. The most gruesome of this attack was, one of the soldier head was decapitated, taken back to Pakistan Kashmir, and brandished as a trophy. As per media reports, Musharaff honored Ilyas Kashmiri for this gruesome act with prize money of one lakh Pakistan rupees.

Terrorism emanating from Pakistan was giving sleepless nights to the Indian government between 1999 and 2000. In 1999, an Indian Airlines airplane (IC-814, enroute from Kathmandu to New Delhi) hijack paved way for the release of Masood Azhar and the birth of a dreadful terrorist group called Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM). A few months later, in October 2001, JeM conducted a suicide bombing in Kashmir legislative assembly killing 38 civilians.

Tragedy struck India again with the dreaded 2001 Bhuj earthquake. Many villages were flattered by the significant number of fatalities from the earthquake. At this moment, Musharaff telephoned Vajpayee and offered humanitarian assistance from Pakistan. This is another ice-breaking moment after the Delhi-Lahore bus confidence building measure (CBM). India accepted the assistance, followed by the Agra summit for peace talks. Agra summit did not yield any major progress, as Musharraf hastily withdrew from the summit as he adamantly wanted to discuss Kashmir on his terms.

9/11 attacks, Indian Parliament Attack, Operation Parakaram


In the 90’s most US citizens believed that their nation is impregnable to any foreign initiated attacks on their homeland. But that belief was shattered on Sept 9, 2001. A few planes struck lofty buildings, bringing down the buildings to rubble. Thousands died in the terror incident, and it questioned the superpower status of the US. In the next few days, Pakistan was coerced to cooperate with the US for upcoming planned retaliations. A few days after 9/11, US deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage discussed with Gen. Mahmoud Ahmed (ISI director). In that he made a direct threat to Ahmed, commonly paraphrased “Pakistan will be bombed to the stone age if it doesn’t cooperate”. Musharaff accepted to help the US in list of planned retaliation activities. He defended saying “We are surrounded by enemies like India/Iran and Pakistan had no other option other than aligning with US interests”.

After the 9/11 terror incident, World changed its perception of militancy and insurgency. Earlier left leaning nations were praising and defending militant activities happening in Palestine, and Kashmir. This perception changed 180 degrees after the 9/11 attacks. Pakistan which earlier protected Kashmir militant groups in name of insurgency faced now serious setback. It was not able to market terror groups like JeM, Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT) in world forums.

Gazi Baba alias Shabaz Khan was one of the most dreaded terrorists in Kashmir insurgency history. He was the brain behind multiple horrendous attacks inside Kashmir valley, those attacks include the 2001 Kashmir assembly suicide bombing, and car bombing attacks on Army headquarters, Srinagar. This time he masterminded an attack outside J&K. On 13th of Dec 2001, the Indian Parliament was infiltrated and attacked by five armed terrorists which resulted in the death of nine Indians, followed by the 2002 Kaluchak Massacre by three fedayeen terrorists that resulted in the deaths of 34 most of whom were wives and children of Indian soldiers.
Kaluchak Massacre Pic Courtesy:OpIndia

Kaluchak Massacre was a watershed moment. It crossed the threshold of the Indian establishment. Enraged India went ahead with Operation Parakaram threatening a limited strike on Pakistan Kashmir targeting camps of JeM, LeT. Both countries enmassed tens of thousands of troops near their borders. Western nations feared a full-blown nuclear war between India and Pakistan. The US and other western countries put significant pressure on Musharaff to act on JeM, LeT. Intense diplomacy between western nations and Musharaff resulted in a commitment by Pakistan, to crack down on jihadi organizations and infrastructure. Both countries withdrww troops after peace negotiations.

Musharaff gave a famous handshake with Musharraf in 2002, peace negotiations thereafter led to the famous 2003 ceasefire agreement between India and Pakistan.

2003 Ceasefire, India Pakistan Peace process




2003 LOC ceasefire is the first and most important confidence-building measure. It is a landmark agreement and it helped in maintaining the peace along the Line of Control (LOC). Villagers along the LOC on both sides were happy with this move. With a ceasefire in place, Indian troops were able to fence the borders effectively, which reduced a significant percentage of militant infiltration from Pakistan Occupied Kashmir. The number of positive developments followed the ceasefire agreement. The peace process followed further with the opening of Indian cinemas to the Pakistan public. After nearly 40 years, Indian films were screened in Pakistan. Like previous army generals, Musharaff used cricket as a diplomacy tool to improve the ties between the two countries. Good bonhomie between the Indian and Pakistan public was highly visible during the India-Pak cricket series. When Indian cricket fans visited Lahore for a cricket match, hotel owners and taxi drivers refused to accept money. Government ministers and lawmakers who visited the Pakistan during cricket series were provided red carpet In Kashmir too, to strengthen CBM, a bus service between Srinagar and Muzaffarabad was inaugurated. Though Musharaff’s four-point solution to Kashmir didn’t get confidence from the Indian establishment, it was a bold attempt to deviate from the previous hard approach of “self-determination” in Kashmir.


As seen in the last several years, whenever the India-Pakistan peace process begins to go positively, there are elements inside Pakistan that sabotage the peace process. During the Musharaff era too this happened multiple times. When Musharaff cracked down on JeM due to US pressure, he faced an assassination attempt in 2004. Kashmir militants were not happy with the peace process after 2003. On the day on which the bus service between Srinagar and Muzaffarabad was inaugurated, there was a bomb attack in the Srinagar Tourism Reception center. United Jihad Council (UJC) leader, Syed Salahuddin once told “Musharraf retreated on Kashmir under international pressure and presented four-point formula without any guarantee

Finally


When Musharaff was ousted in 2008, he left a mixed legacy concerning India-Pakistan relations. The peace process that was developed during his regime was completely stalled due to the 2008 Mumbai terror attacks. India-Pakistan relations have never attained that zenith once achieved during the Musharaff era again in the last few years. In the last few months when he ruled, terrorism and violence started to rise significantly in Pakistan, which later created mayhem inside Pakistan for the next several years from 2008. When Musharaff left, Kashmir’s moderate separatist leader, Mirwaiz Umar Farroq, was dismayed by his ouster, while the hardline faction of the Syed Ali Shah Geelani camp celebrated his removal.